Read About Our Updated Shipping Policy Here
1 3

Shoofly Pie

$9.99 USD
Size

Delivery and Shipping
  • Shipping charges are calculated based on the shipping address.
  • 2 Day Transit Time
  • Orders are processed and shipped Monday-Wednesday. Orders placed after 9am Wednesday-Sunday will be processed and shipped the next week.
  • Ice Packs and Thicker Liners used for Hotter Months/Locations
  • See our Shipping Statement page for more details. We do not ship to PO Boxes; please include a physical address in your order.

Cooking and Care Instructions

Ready to eat. Shelf stable. Can be frozen. Goes great with ice cream.

Ingredients and Nutrition Facts

Ingredients: Brown Sugar, Molasses, Unbleached Wheat Flour, Eggs, Shortening, Corn Starch, Baking Soda, Cinnamon, Salt. Contains: Wheat, Eggs.

A PA Dutch Classic

Description

Our Shoofly Pie is a Lancaster County favorite consisting of a wet-bottom of molasses topped with bread crumbs. Served with ice cream, it's the perfect end to any meal. A true PA Dutch dessert classic.

Reviews (3)

Customer Reviews

Based on 3 reviews Write a review

Payment & Security

Payment methods

  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Diners Club
  • Discover
  • Google Pay
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • Shop Pay
  • Venmo
  • Visa

Your payment information is processed securely. We do not store credit card details nor have access to your credit card information.

Customer Reviews

Based on 14 reviews
50%
(7)
14%
(2)
21%
(3)
14%
(2)
0%
(0)
100.0
92.9
F
Faith A York
delicious shoofly pie!

Love your pies - they're worth shipping! thank you!

J
Jeffrey

Yummy product

M
Maureen Berkovich
Gift

Whenever I order meat, I get a Shoofly pie for my friend. She really enjoys them !

Thank you so much for sharing our products, Maureen, it is such a compliment! We hope you both enjoy!

T
Twila Stephens
Mostly crumbs

I was really looking forward to the Shoofly Pie; haven't had it in many many years. Maybe a 6-in pie doesn't leave a lot of room for the gooey good stuff. Every bite was a mouthful of dry crumbs.

Hi Twila. We are so sorry to hear that the shoofly pie did not meet your expectations! We will discuss this as a team and see if there are changes that need to be made. Thank you for sharing your feedback!

S
Stephanie Gamberg
Product review

Pie was good, but too much topping. The filling tasted more like pecan pie filling and not molasses.

Thank you for sharing your feedback, we appreciate hearing from you!

123
Shoofly Pie - Stoltzfus Meats
Stoltzfus Meats

Shoofly Pie

From $9.99 USD

Our Shoofly Pie is a Lancaster County favorite consisting of a wet-bottom of molasses topped with bread crumbs. Served with ice cream, it's the perfect end to any meal. A true PA Dutch dessert classic.


Size

  • 6 inch
  • 8 inch
View product
Back to top