icon
Left Continue shopping
Your Order

You have no items in your cart

You might like
From $10.99
Show options
From $14.99
Show options

Baked Goods

The place to find baked goods like shoofly pies, chocolate chip cookies, and energy bites, along with bulk items such as homemade granola, and soup mixes. Restock your pantry or satisfy your sweet tooth with baked goods delivery!

Order baked goods online and you’ll have the best of Lancaster County treats and Amish desserts on hand anytime. Imagine the faces of family and guests when you present them with peanut butter pockets or our salted caramel sugar cookies. So many baked goods to choose, come back often to try them all.

Baked Goods

Filter

Availability
Price
$
$
Product type
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough - Stoltzfus Meats
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough

1 review
$14.99
Whoopie Pies - Stoltzfus Meats
Whoopie Pies

2 reviews
From $8.99
Shoofly Pie - Stoltzfus Meats
Shoofly Pie

1 review
From $6.99
Dried Soup Mix - Stoltzfus Meats
Dried Soup Mix

1 review
From $5.99
Energy Bites - Stoltzfus Meats
Peanut Butter Pockets - Stoltzfus Meats
Peanut Butter Pockets (12 Pack)

1 review
$8.99
Salted Caramel Sugar Cookies - Stoltzfus Meats
Oatmeal Raisin Cookies - Stoltzfus Meats
Chocolate Chip Cookies - Stoltzfus Meats
Pumpkin Roll (23 oz.)

1 review
$14.99
Old Fashioned Sand Tarts

2 reviews
From $10.99